American College of Physicians advises against EKGs, stress testing, among others
WebMD News from HealthDay
By Randy Dotinga
TUESDAY, March 17, 2015 (HealthDay News) -- Many patients who are at low risk for heart problems don't need to have screening tests such as EKGs and stress tests, a national association of primary care physicians recommends.
The new guideline jibes with research that has suggested the tests are overused in patients who don't need them.
"These tests are very unlikely to be helpful in low-risk patients. They are unlikely to give findings that will change patient management or improve patient outcomes," said Dr. Roger Chou, director of the Pacific Northwest Evidence-based Practice Center at Oregon Health & Science University. He is the lead author of the guidelines that were released Monday by the American College of Physicians.
At issue are electrocardiography (EKG or ECG), echocardiography (echo) and myocardial perfusion imaging (nuclear) tests. All of these can be used in "stress tests" that require patients to be monitored as they exercise. EKG tests can also be used in patients who aren't moving.
The new recommendations noted that no current screening guidelines appear to recommend cardiac screening in low-risk adults without symptoms. Still, many patients undergo the tests, Chou said. He pointed to a Consumer Reports survey that found 39 percent of adults without certain cardiac symptoms said they'd undergone the tests within the past five years.
Chou said doctors could find other ways to gauge the cardiac condition of patients who are at low risk. They can do this by using a cardiovascular risk "calculator" that takes various factors into account, he said.
"The percentage of patients that fit in the category of low risk varies, depending on age and sex," Chou said. "For example, most women in their 40s and 50s will be in the low-risk category. The risk goes up with age, and men tend to have higher risk than women."
If low-risk people do get unneeded cardiac screening, the study said, they could face unnecessary future testing because of "false positives" -- results that falsely suggest a problem -- and unnecessarily be exposed to radiation in nuclear stress tests.
source : New Guidelines Call for No Heart Tests for Low-Risk Patients